Should Jason Todd have stayed dead?

[The_Mad_Dragon Captain Pervert Find all posts View Profile Close The_Mad_Dragon]

For me, they ruined the Todd.

[Jack-O-Lantern Master Customizer Find all posts View Profile Close Jack-O-Lantern]

I think he should have. But surprisingly, they've kept him interesting and made somewhat decent use of him.

[Kuhan Moderator Find all posts View Profile Close Kuhan]

a. This should be in other comics

b. His return was pointless, but now that he's back, I'm really enjoying him as a character.

[W.West Moderator Find all posts View Profile Close W.West]

Should be moved..I think you've been here long enough to realize that. lol

And it makes no difference to me. Nothing in comics is sacred, and as long as a good story is told in the process then I'm happy.

[Marvelous Iggy God Of Turtles Find all posts View Profile Close Marvelous Iggy]

continuity punch!!!!

[The_Mad_Dragon Captain Pervert Find all posts View Profile Close The_Mad_Dragon]

Should be moved..I think you've been here long enough to realize that. lol

Meh. A mod will move it for me. Besides, I didn't feel like putting all the effort into scrolling down.

[Guest Close Kuma]

Id be ok with him if it werent for Countdown

[JME2 Corps Honor Guard Find all posts View Profile Close JME2]

His return worked fine for the context of "Under the Hood", but it would have been deliciously ironic fro the Joker to have killed him a second time when the warehouse came crashing down in Batman # 650. Or, the original intention of having him be the Earth-2 Jason would have been an even better twist. But, we get retcon punch and his continued existence and the Bat mythos is thus straddled with a dull, uninteresting addition.

[ion.nai existential absurdist Find all posts View Profile Close ion.nai]

Todd should be dead.
The Red Robin costume is cool, but they could have easily had anyone take up the mantle.

[Old School Guardian of the Universe Find all posts View Profile Close Old School]

the punch was kinda dumb, The story though that surrounded I thought was cool as hell.

Im glad hes back. makes my phone call over 20 years worth something now

[Godmera Champion of the World Find all posts View Profile Close Godmera]

Yes,

[Old School Guardian of the Universe Find all posts View Profile Close Old School]

[QUOTE=JME2;141030]His return worked fine for the context of "Under the Hood", but it would have been deliciously ironic fro the Joker to have killed him a second time when the warehouse came crashing down in Batman # 650. Or, the original intention of having him be the Earth-2 Jason would have been an even better twist. But, we get retcon punch and his continued existence and the Bat mythos is thus straddled with a dull, uninteresting addition.[/QUOTE]


you mean like batwoman?

[Old School Guardian of the Universe Find all posts View Profile Close Old School]

Todd should be dead.
The Red Robin costume is cool, but they could have easily had anyone take up the mantle.

easily yes, but then that would be to easy.

[Guest Close Kuma]

I actually like the Batwoman/Question/Spectre stories

[W.West Moderator Find all posts View Profile Close W.West]

you mean like batwoman?

Um, I'd love to know where you've actually read a full on Batwoman story. Its kinda hard to call a character dull before she can express her personality...